Dairy ยท Physical interventions
Are dairy cows' horns removed?
Usual: calves are dehorned and some cows have docked tails. Furthest along: Certified Humane dairy. Weakest: 7 standards, among them Legal minimum (federal; no federal dairy welfare law) and USDA Organic milk (7 CFR 205).
Why it is like this
About 94 in 100 US dairy farms routinely dehorned their heifer calves in 2014, and 30 percent of the hot-iron users gave a painkiller (USDA NAHMS). Federal law sets no limit. USDA Organic bans tail docking but not dehorning.
What the labels say
| Standard | Level |
|---|---|
| Legal minimum (federal; no federal dairy welfare law) | 1 Always, if it makes keeping the animals easier |
| USDA Organic milk (7 CFR 205) | 1 Always, if it makes keeping the animals easier |
| Certified Humane dairy | 1-2 level 1 guaranteed (Always, if it makes keeping the animals easier); up to level 2 depending on the farm |
| Animal Welfare Approved dairy | 1 Always, if it makes keeping the animals easier |
| American Humane Certified dairy | 1 Always, if it makes keeping the animals easier |
| Regenerative Organic Certified dairy, Bronze | 1 Always, if it makes keeping the animals easier |
| Regenerative Organic Certified dairy, Silver | 1 Always, if it makes keeping the animals easier |
| Regenerative Organic Certified dairy, Gold | 1 Always, if it makes keeping the animals easier |
How we read the levels
- Always, if it makes keeping the animals easier.
- Only if the animals might otherwise injure themselves with them.
- Only if a particular animal needs treatment itself.
- Never. The animal keeps everything it was born with.
Level 1: Always, if it makes keeping the animals easier.
Applies to: Legal minimum (federal; no federal dairy welfare law), USDA Organic milk (7 CFR 205), Certified Humane dairy, Animal Welfare Approved dairy, American Humane Certified dairy, Regenerative Organic Certified dairy, Bronze, Regenerative Organic Certified dairy, Silver and Regenerative Organic Certified dairy, Gold
Federal law does not limit dehorning or disbudding of calves, and USDA Organic bans only tail docking of cattle. In 2014 about 94 of 100 dairy farms routinely dehorned their heifer calves.
NAHMS Dairy 2014: 94.3 percent of operations with 30 or more cows routinely dehorned heifer calves; among those, 74.2 percent used a hot iron or electric dehorner, and 30.0 percent of the hot-iron users gave a painkiller or anesthetic. About one third of cows had docked tails across the study years. USDA Organic 205.238(a)(5)(ii) prohibits tail docking of cattle and does not address dehorning. AWA (4.8.7) and American Humane allow caustic paste on calves up to 7 days old without pain relief, which is level 1. Certified Humane asks for pain management at every disbudding, hot iron or paste, so it sits between levels 1 and 2 and we keep the lower.
What stays open
No rule on this is known for this standard.
Videos
Note: this video shows images some people find distressing.
Disbudding calvesUC Davis Center for Animal Welfare, 7 minThe UC Davis animal welfare center shows how calves are disbudded, which means removing the horn buds. Shows the procedure.
Sources
- USDA APHIS NAHMS: Trends in Dairy Cattle Health and Management Practices in the United States, 1991-2014 (Dairy 2014)
- 7 CFR 205.238 Livestock care and production practices standard (eCFR)
- Certified Humane (HFAC) Standards for Dairy Cattle, 2025 print
- AWA Dairy Cattle Standards 2026 v1
- American Humane Certified Dairy Cattle Standards, revision date February 2020 on the cover (file posted February 2025)
- Animal Welfare Act definitions, 7 USC 2132(g) (Cornell LII): 'animal' means warm-blooded animals and excludes livestock and poultry used for food or fiber; no federal rule on farm housing, space, outdoor access, weaning or alterations (no rule)
- Regenerative Organic Certified Framework Guidance, Animal Welfare, v1.2, 4 December 2023
- Everything on Dairy
- How long do dairy cows live?
- Are calves separated from their mothers?
- How much room do dairy cows have?
- What do dairy cows lie on?
- Do dairy cows get to graze on pasture?
- How long are cows transported?
- How are dairy cows slaughtered?
- Label: Legal minimum (federal law)
- Label: USDA Organic
- Label: Certified Humane
- Label: Animal Welfare Approved (AWA)
- Label: American Humane Certified
- Label: Regenerative Organic Certified (dairy)
- Legal minimum (federal law) vs USDA Organic: Dairy
- Legal minimum (federal law) vs Certified Humane: Dairy
- Legal minimum (federal law) vs Animal Welfare Approved (AWA): Dairy
- Legal minimum (federal law) vs American Humane Certified: Dairy