Fish · Death
How are fish killed?
Wild fish have no killing rule, and by our reading the law does not require farmed fish to be stunned either. Furthest along: RSPCA Assured salmon. Weakest: 4 standards, among them Wild-caught fish (no scheme) and MSC (wild-caught).
Why it is like this
Wild-caught fish: no law or label we read has a killing rule for them, and the MSC pages describe none. Farmed fish: Article 1(1) of retained Regulation 1099/2009 applies only Article 3(1) to fish, a general duty to spare avoidable pain, so the stunning duty of Article 4 does not cover them. RSPCA Assured salmon bans six killing methods, including ice slurry and carbon dioxide. The ASC label exists for farmed fish only, and its salmon standard in force has no stunning rule. Its new Farm Standard takes effect on 1 February 2027 and becomes mandatory on 1 May 2028; it requires stunning and checks that at least 95% of fish lose consciousness at once. The EU authority EFSA rated killing farmed trout by suffocation as a severe welfare hazard (2009). No fish product reaches a death without fear.
What the labels say
| Standard | Level |
|---|---|
| Wild-caught fish (no scheme) | 1 I don't care how it dies |
| MSC (wild-caught) | 1 I don't care how it dies |
| Legal minimum farmed fish (law in England) | 1 I don't care how it dies |
| RSPCA Assured salmon | 3 It should feel no pain, even if it may be afraid beforehand |
| Organic salmon, GB regulation | 2-3 level 2 guaranteed (It may feel brief fear or pain if it is quick); up to level 3 depending on the farm |
| ASC (farmed salmon) | 1 I don't care how it dies |
How we read the levels
- I don't care how it dies.
- It may feel brief fear or pain if it is quick.
- It should feel no pain, even if it may be afraid beforehand.
- It should die without fear and without pain, and notice nothing of it.
Level 1: I don't care how it dies.
Applies to: Wild-caught fish (no scheme), MSC (wild-caught), Legal minimum farmed fish (law in England) and ASC (farmed salmon)
Wild-caught fish, with or without the MSC label, have no killing rule in any law or label we read. For farmed fish, by our reading, the law on killing does not require stunning either: only the general duty to spare avoidable pain (Article 3(1)) applies. ASC, a label for farmed fish only, is at this level too until its new standard applies in 2027.
Article 1(1) of retained Regulation 1099/2009 says that as regards fish, only the requirements laid down in Article 3(1) apply. Article 3(1) reads that animals shall be spared any avoidable pain, distress or suffering during killing and related operations. The stunning duty sits in Article 4, which does not mention fish. The English killing rules (SI 2015/1782) define “animal” in Schedule 1, where the stunning methods are listed, as solipeds, ruminants, pigs, rabbits, poultry or ratites, so fish are not in it either (all seen on legislation.gov.uk, 2026-11-21). The ASC label exists for farmed fish only. Its Salmon Standard v1.4, in force since 1 February 2023, has no rule on stunning or slaughter, so ASC salmon takes the legal level. The ASC Farm Standard V1.1 applies from 1 February 2027: all fish stunned before killing (4.1.3.2), and once the transition period for a species ends, at least 95% of fish unconscious at once, the rest re-stunned, and checks that opercular, eye and body movements have stopped (4.1.3.5, 4.1.3.6). We will score it when it applies. Wild-caught fish are a separate case: no law or label we read has a killing rule for them, and the MSC fisheries standard pages describe a sustainability and ecosystem standard and mention none.
Level 2: It may feel brief fear or pain if it is quick.
Applies to: Organic salmon, GB regulation
Organic salmon under the retained regulation must be rendered unconscious, with no method list or checks. We place it between Level 2 and Level 3.
Retained Regulation 889/2008, Art 25h(5): slaughter techniques shall render fish immediately unconscious and insensible to pain (seen 2026-11-21). The Annex on stocking densities has no slaughter text. A set result without a written check sits between Level 2 and Level 3, and the lower level counts. ASC salmon is on Level 1 until its Farm Standard applies (see Level 1).
Level 3: It should feel no pain, even if it may be afraid beforehand.
Applies to: RSPCA Assured salmon
Possible on some farms, not guaranteed: Organic salmon, GB regulation
RSPCA Assured salmon must be stunned or killed by a method that makes the fish insensible quickly, and six methods are banned outright, including ice slurry and carbon dioxide.
S 1.3 bans bleeding or decapitation without prior stunning, asphyxia, evisceration, live chilling, ice slurry or bath, and carbon dioxide narcosis. S 1.5 requires a method that rapidly renders the fish insensible, without pain and distress, until death. S 1.6 says humane automated mechanical devices must be used in preference to a manual percussive blow, except in emergencies. ES 1.1 to ES 1.4 set checks for any electrical process, and fish that are not stunned effectively must be re-stunned at once. A written stun check with re-stunning is Level 3 on the scale; nothing shows the fish feel no fear beforehand.
What stays open
We have no killing rule for wild-caught fish, and no fish scheme in our data promises a death without fear or pain.
Sources
- MSC Fisheries Standard version 3.1, web pages only (the standard PDF itself was not found)
- ASC Salmon Standard v1.4, issued 5 September 2022, effective 1 February 2023 (https://peru.controlunion.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/5/2023/08/9__asc-salmon-standard-v1_4-final.pdf)
- ASC Farm Standard V1.1 (ASC-STD-001), published 1 November 2026, effective 1 February 2027
- RSPCA welfare standards for farmed Atlantic salmon, May 2024
- Council Reg (EC) 1099/2009 as retained, Arts 1, 2 and 4 (the stunning duty does not cover fish)
- Commission Reg (EC) 889/2008 as retained, Art 25h (aquaculture animal husbandry, para 5 on slaughter)
- Source also used in the German table (not reopened for the UK): EFSA 2009: killing of rainbow trout (opinion)
- Everything on Fish
- How old are fish when they are killed for food?
- Do farmed fish ever see their parents?
- How much space do farmed fish have?
- What does a farmed fish's habitat look like?
- Do farmed fish live outdoors?
- What treatments do farmed fish get?
- How long are live fish transported?
- Label: Wild-caught fish
- Label: Legal minimum (law in England)
- Label: RSPCA Assured
- Label: GB organic regulation (other certifiers)
- Label: ASC (farmed salmon)
- Legal minimum (law in England) vs RSPCA Assured: Fish
- Legal minimum (law in England) vs GB organic regulation (other certifiers): Fish
- RSPCA Assured vs GB organic regulation (other certifiers): Fish