Fish ยท Physical interventions
What treatments do farmed fish get?
Only RSPCA Assured bans mutilations of salmon. Level at the front: Wild-caught fish (no scheme) and MSC (wild-caught). Weakest: Legal minimum farmed fish (law in England) and ASC (farmed salmon).
Why it is like this
The RSPCA Assured salmon standard prohibits mutilations that remove sensitive tissue, which we place between Level 3 and Level 4. Organic salmon is at Level 2, the level our scale gives every organic row. The law and ASC have no rule on this, which is Level 1.
What the labels say
| Standard | Level |
|---|---|
| Wild-caught fish (no scheme) | 4 Never. The animal keeps everything it was born with |
| MSC (wild-caught) | 4 Never. The animal keeps everything it was born with |
| Legal minimum farmed fish (law in England) | 1 Always, if it makes keeping the animals easier |
| RSPCA Assured salmon | 3-4 level 3 guaranteed (Only if a particular animal needs treatment itself); up to level 4 depending on the farm |
| Organic salmon, GB regulation | 2 Only if the animals might otherwise injure themselves with them |
| ASC (farmed salmon) | 1 Always, if it makes keeping the animals easier |
How we read the levels
- Always, if it makes keeping the animals easier.
- Only if the animals might otherwise injure themselves with them.
- Only if a particular animal needs treatment itself.
- Never. The animal keeps everything it was born with.
Level 1: Always, if it makes keeping the animals easier.
Applies to: Legal minimum farmed fish (law in England) and ASC (farmed salmon)
The law has no rule on procedures for farmed fish, and neither does the ASC salmon standard. That is Level 1.
Fish are outside the 2007 farm welfare regulations (reg 3(2)(a)), and the procedure rules for other farm animals do not cover them. The Scottish regulations, where the Scottish salmon we priced was farmed, leave fish out in the same way (reg 3(2)(a) of the 2010 Regulations). We found no rule on procedures in the ASC Salmon Standard v1.4.
Level 2: Only if the animals might otherwise injure themselves with them.
Applies to: Organic salmon, GB regulation
Organic salmon sits at Level 2, the level our scale gives every organic row unless its own text bans more.
The organic livestock rules allow physical procedures only case by case and with anaesthesia or pain relief (Reg 834/2007, Art 14(1)(b)(viii); Reg 889/2008, Art 18), and our scale puts every organic row at Level 2 unless its own text bans more. The aquaculture articles we read (Reg 834/2007, Art 15; Reg 889/2008, Art 25h) name no procedure for fish, so this level is our reading of the organic rules as a whole.
Level 3: Only if a particular animal needs treatment itself.
Applies to: RSPCA Assured salmon
RSPCA Assured salmon prohibits mutilations that remove sensitive tissue. We place it between Level 3 and Level 4, because we have not yet searched the standard for exceptions.
The health chapter of the RSPCA Assured salmon standard says that mutilations involving the removal of sensitive tissue are prohibited, and that marking methods causing distress or injury must not be used. A general ban is Level 3 or higher; a ban by name with no exception in the whole text would be Level 4. Until the exceptions are checked, the cell runs from 3 to 4.
Level 4: Never. The animal keeps everything it was born with.
Applies to: Wild-caught fish (no scheme) and MSC (wild-caught)
Possible on some farms, not guaranteed: RSPCA Assured salmon
Nothing is done to the animal until it is caught. This is the wild fish. Injuries from nets and bycatch are not counted here.
Nothing is done to the animal until it is caught. This is the wild fish. Injuries from nets and bycatch are not counted here. Wild catch is not covered by a farm rule document, so this level comes from the biology of the fish before capture, not from a written rule. It says nothing about the catch itself.
What stays open
Beyond the rules on the level pages, we found no fixed rule on routine procedures for fish.
Videos
Note: this video shows images some people find distressing.
Salmon Suffering In Scottish Fish FarmsCompassion in World Farming, 3 minFootage of injured fish in Scottish salmon farms, from an advocacy group.
Sources
- Same Regs, reg 3 (reg 3(2)(a): fish, reptiles and amphibians are not 'farmed animals', so the Regulations do not apply to fish)
- Welfare of Farmed Animals (Scotland) Regulations 2010 (SSI 2010/388), reg 3(2)(a): fish are not farmed animals under these Regulations
- ASC Salmon Standard v1.4, issued 5 September 2022, effective 1 February 2023 (https://peru.controlunion.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/5/2023/08/9__asc-salmon-standard-v1_4-final.pdf)
- Council Reg (EC) 834/2007 as retained, Art 14 (livestock rules)
- Commission Reg (EC) 889/2008 as retained, Art 18 (management of animals, physical operations)
- Council Reg (EC) 834/2007 as retained, Art 15 (aquaculture rules)
- Commission Reg (EC) 889/2008 as retained, Art 25h (aquaculture animal husbandry, para 5 on slaughter)
- RSPCA welfare standards for farmed Atlantic salmon, May 2024
- Wild fish: the levels come from the biology of the fish, not from a written rule; the fish lives free in sea, lake or river until it is caught
- MSC Fisheries Standard version 3.1, web pages only (the standard PDF itself was not found)
- Everything on Fish
- How old are fish when they are killed for food?
- Do farmed fish ever see their parents?
- How much space do farmed fish have?
- What does a farmed fish's habitat look like?
- Do farmed fish live outdoors?
- How long are live fish transported?
- How are fish killed?
- Label: Wild-caught fish
- Label: Legal minimum (law in England)
- Label: RSPCA Assured
- Label: GB organic regulation (other certifiers)
- Label: ASC (farmed salmon)
- Legal minimum (law in England) vs RSPCA Assured: Fish
- Legal minimum (law in England) vs GB organic regulation (other certifiers): Fish
- RSPCA Assured vs GB organic regulation (other certifiers): Fish