Fish ยท Physical interventions
What treatments do farmed fish get?
The farmed salmon sold here comes from Norway, where the law bans operations on live fish except by a vet or fish health biologist. Level at the front: Wild fish without label and Wild fish with MSC. Weakest: EU organic leaf, farmed fish (Skal).
Why it is like this
Norwegian law applies to salmon with and without ASC; it allows marking as well. Fish farmed in the Netherlands fall under the Wet dieren, which bans physical interventions on kept animals unless a vet finds them necessary or a decree allows them. The decree names pigs, cattle and other mammals and birds, not fish.
What the labels say
| Standard | Level |
|---|---|
| Wild fish without label | 4 Never. The animal keeps everything it was born with |
| Wild fish with MSC | 4 Never. The animal keeps everything it was born with |
| Farmed salmon without label (legal minimum, farmed in Norway) | 3 Only if a particular animal needs treatment itself |
| ASC farmed salmon (farmed in Norway) | 3 Only if a particular animal needs treatment itself |
| EU organic leaf, farmed fish (Skal) | 2 Only if the animals might otherwise injure themselves with them |
How we read the levels
- Always, if it makes keeping the animals easier.
- Only if the animals might otherwise injure themselves with them.
- Only if a particular animal needs treatment itself.
- Never. The animal keeps everything it was born with.
Level 2: Only if the animals might otherwise injure themselves with them.
Applies to: EU organic leaf, farmed fish (Skal)
Only if the animals might otherwise injure each other. EU organic fish sits here: the EU organic rules allow interventions only case by case, and we found no source on where the organic fish sold in the Netherlands is farmed.
Regulation 2018/848 allows interventions only case by case. Without a sourced origin we cite no national law for organic fish.
Level 3: Only if a particular animal needs treatment itself.
Applies to: Farmed salmon without label (legal minimum, farmed in Norway) and ASC farmed salmon (farmed in Norway)
Only if a particular animal needs treatment: Norwegian law bans operations on live fish except marking and work by a vet or fish health biologist, and salmon from Norway, with and without ASC, sits here. For fish farmed in the Netherlands, Dutch law also bans physical interventions unless a vet finds them necessary or a decree allows them, and no decree names fish.
Wet dieren art. 2.8. The Besluit diergeneeskundigen names pigs, cattle and other animals, not fish. This holds for fish farmed in the Netherlands. Salmon farmed in Norway, with and without ASC, falls under the Akvakulturdriftsforskriften (para 31, as read for our Norway table).
Level 4: Never. The animal keeps everything it was born with.
Applies to: Wild fish without label and Wild fish with MSC
The animal keeps everything it was born with. This applies to wild fish.
This is our own reading. Wild fish are not handled by farms.
What stays open
No label rule on interventions for farmed fish was found, so farmed fish takes the legal value of the country where it is farmed: Norwegian law for the salmon sold here with and without ASC. For organic fish of unknown origin the EU organic rule counts.
Videos
Note: this video shows images some people find distressing.
Salmon Suffering In Scottish Fish FarmsCompassion in World Farming, 3 minFootage from Scottish salmon farms, not Dutch ones. English only; fills the fish gap. From an advocacy group.
Sources
- Regulation (EU) 2018/848, Annex II Part II (livestock), original text
- Wet dieren art. 2.8 (physical interventions banned unless veterinary necessity or designated) with Besluit diergeneeskundigen art. 2.2 (poultry; beak treatment was phased out from 1 September 2018 and is now only possible under the temporary exemption in Regeling diergeneeskundigen art. 7.3, which ended for laying hens on 1 January 2019, see stcrt), 2.3 (pigs: castration, tail docking up to 4 days, teeth filing up to 7 days, the last two only after injuries are seen and other measures failed), 2.4 (cattle: dehorning, nose ring for breeding bulls), 2.7 (no unnecessary pain)
- Akvakulturdriftsforskriften (FOR-2008-06-17-822), Norwegian aquaculture regulation, paras 25, 31 and 34, as read for our Norway table
- Wild catch: the fish lives free until caught (our own reading)
- Everything on Fish
- How old are fish when they are killed for food?
- Do farmed fish ever see their parents?
- How much space do farmed fish have?
- What does a farmed fish's habitat look like?
- Do farmed fish live outdoors?
- How long are live fish transported?
- How are fish killed?
- Label: Wild-caught fish without a label
- Label: MSC (wild-caught fish)
- Label: Legal minimum (law)
- Label: ASC (farmed fish)
- Label: EU organic (Skal)
- Legal minimum (law) vs EU organic (Skal): Fish