How my food lives
Switzerland
DEENFRIT

Fish · Death

How are fish killed?

Last updated: November 2026

Wild fish mostly die in air, on ice or when gutted. Farmed fish must be stunned. Level at the front: Naturland aquaculture trout and salmon (pond, net pens) and Naturland aquaculture carp (pond). Weakest: Wild-caught (no label) and MSC wild catch (Fisheries Standard v3.1).

Why it is like this

The MSC standard has no rule on how the fish die. According to a 2025 systematic review, most wild fish that are alive when landed die in air, on ice or when gutted. For farmed fish the law requires stunning, and ASC requires that at least 95 of 100 fish are unconscious at once. Swiss law does not apply to imported wild catch. In 2025 only 2.7 percent of the Swiss fish supply came from domestic production, and the supply was 8.38 kilograms per person.

What the labels say

StandardLevel
Legal minimum for farmed fish (Animal Welfare Ordinance, TSchV)2 It may feel brief fear or pain if it is quick
Wild-caught (no label)1 I don't care how it dies
MSC wild catch (Fisheries Standard v3.1)1 I don't care how it dies
ASC farmed salmon (Farm Standard or Salmon Standard v1.4)2-3 level 2 guaranteed (It may feel brief fear or pain if it is quick); up to level 3 depending on the farm
Knospe trout and salmon (tanks, net pens)2 It may feel brief fear or pain if it is quick
Knospe carp (natural pond)2 It may feel brief fear or pain if it is quick
Naturland aquaculture trout and salmon (pond, net pens)3 It should feel no pain, even if it may be afraid beforehand
Naturland aquaculture carp (pond)3 It should feel no pain, even if it may be afraid beforehand
How we read the levels
  1. I don't care how it dies.
  2. It may feel brief fear or pain if it is quick.
  3. It should feel no pain, even if it may be afraid beforehand.
  4. It should die without fear and without pain, and notice nothing of it.

Level 1: I don't care how it dies.

Applies to: Wild-caught (no label) and MSC wild catch (Fisheries Standard v3.1)

Most wild fish that are alive when landed suffocate in air or on ice or are gutted alive. This holds for wild catch without a label and with MSC; the MSC label has no rule on this.

The MSC standard v3.1 (271 pages with guidance) contains, in a full-text search for stunning, killing and slaughter, only "intentional killing" of marine mammals as bycatch, and nothing on how the fish die. Swiss law requires stunning (Art. 178 TSchV); catching in Switzerland must be gentle, and fish meant for eating must be killed without delay (Art. 100). For fish caught elsewhere and imported, Swiss law does not apply. A systematic review in Animal Welfare (James and others, 2025) states that most wild-caught fish that are alive when landed die from asphyxiation in air or ice, or from evisceration.

Level 2: It may feel brief fear or pain if it is quick.

Applies to: Legal minimum for farmed fish (Animal Welfare Ordinance, TSchV), ASC farmed salmon (Farm Standard or Salmon Standard v1.4), Knospe trout and salmon (tanks, net pens) and Knospe carp (natural pond)

Farmed fish must be stunned: a blow to the head, neck break, electricity and mechanical destruction of the brain are allowed. That is the case under the law and at Knospe. For ASC salmon from Norway, Norwegian law requires stunning before killing.

Stunning is compulsory (Art. 178 TSchV), the permitted methods are in Art. 179a lit. i, and after stunning fish may be gutted instead of bled (Art. 179d para. 5). Knospe: fish may be killed only under stunning, in the water or immediately after removal, and must then be gutted or processed without delay (5.7.7). No standard assesses the waiting and herding before stunning. For salmon from Norway, akvakulturdriftsforskriften § 34 applies: fish must be stunned before killing and still be stunned when death occurs. Until 1 May 2028 many ASC farms may still be audited against the older ASC Salmon Standard v1.4, which by our reading for the Norway table has no rule on stunning. That is why ASC sits at 2 to 3.

Level 3: It should feel no pain, even if it may be afraid beforehand.

Applies to: Naturland aquaculture trout and salmon (pond, net pens) and Naturland aquaculture carp (pond)

Possible on some farms, not guaranteed: ASC farmed salmon (Farm Standard or Salmon Standard v1.4)

Stunning with an effect check: ASC requires that at least 95 of 100 fish are unconscious at once and bans CO2, salt bath, ammonia bath and suffocation in air. Naturland checks the eye reflex, breathing and muscle twitching. For ASC this holds only for farms already audited against the new Farm Standard.

ASC (4.1.3.2 to 4.1.3.6): stunning of all fish, checks of gill, eye and body movement and pain response. Naturland (Part B I 10.2): blow to the head or electro-narcosis, an effect check and re-stunning if it fails, and for carp electrical stunning followed by a blow to the head. No standard assesses the waiting and herding before stunning, and we did not check the origin and share of ASC and Naturland fish in Swiss shops. The rule is in the new ASC Farm Standard. It is mandatory only for audits from 1 May 2028, and until then farms may still be audited against the old species standards (ASC, Farm Standard page). For ASC, 3 is therefore only the upper end.

What stays open

There is no stunning rule where MSC is silent. For wild catch, suffocation, crushing or gutting while conscious is usual.

Sources

More on this