Fish · Death
How are fish killed?
Wild fish mostly die in the net, in the air or on ice. Here the standards barely differ: 6 reach level 2.
Why it is like this
Most wild-caught fish are crushed in the net, suffocate in the air, are put on ice or gutted alive, and that can take hours. The MSC label has no rule on this either. The EU agency EFSA rates killing trout by suffocation as a severe burden. AMA-Gütesiegel Fisch and BIO AUSTRIA require stunning before slaughter. A death without fear is reached by no fish product.
What the labels say
| Standard | Level |
|---|---|
| AMA-Gütesiegel fish (Austria) | 2 It may feel brief fear or pain if it is quick |
| BIO AUSTRIA carp (pond) | 2 It may feel brief fear or pain if it is quick |
| BIO AUSTRIA trout (pond, flow channel) | 2 It may feel brief fear or pain if it is quick |
| Organic (EU) aquaculture (salmon, trout) | 2-3 level 2 guaranteed (It may feel brief fear or pain if it is quick); up to level 3 depending on the farm |
| Wild fish with the MSC label | 1 I don't care how it dies |
| Salmon with the ASC label | 2-3 level 2 guaranteed (It may feel brief fear or pain if it is quick); up to level 3 depending on the farm |
| Naturland aquaculture | 2-3 level 2 guaranteed (It may feel brief fear or pain if it is quick); up to level 3 depending on the farm |
How we read the levels
- I don't care how it dies.
- It may feel brief fear or pain if it is quick.
- It should feel no pain, even if it may be afraid beforehand.
- It should die without fear and without pain, and notice nothing of it.
Level 1: I don't care how it dies.
Applies to: Wild fish with the MSC label
Most wild-caught fish are crushed in the net, suffocate in air, are put on ice or gutted alive. That holds for wild catch without a label and with MSC. The MSC label has no rule on this either.
Without gutting, it takes 55 to 250 minutes by Fishcount until herring, cod, whiting, sole, dab and plaice are unconscious. When gutted alive, 25 to 65 minutes (Fishcount, Dutch study). An estimated 1.1 to 2.2 trillion fish are caught a year. Only 12 of 223 studies on stunning concerned wild fish, 7 of them on fishing vessels (Faunalytics).
Level 2: It may feel brief fear or pain if it is quick.
Applies to: AMA-Gütesiegel fish (Austria), BIO AUSTRIA carp (pond), BIO AUSTRIA trout (pond, flow channel), Organic (EU) aquaculture (salmon, trout), Salmon with the ASC label and Naturland aquaculture
Farmed fish may only be slaughtered after stunning: AMA-Gütesiegel Fisch requires proper stunning, BIO AUSTRIA immediate stunning without pain. That is the position for farmed salmon, pond fish and everyone who regulates nothing beyond it.
AMA-Gütesiegel Fisch: fish may only be slaughtered after proper stunning (guideline 2015, section 6). BIO AUSTRIA 3.13.6.1: care is taken that the animals are stunned at once and feel no pain. The rules do not say how stunning is checked. Not confirmed: whether and how stunning is checked for farmed salmon and ASC we did not check for Austria; the old ASC salmon standard v1.4 has no rule on it. We did not read the Austrian law on slaughtering farmed fish (Tierschutz-Schlachtverordnung).
Level 3: It should feel no pain, even if it may be afraid beforehand.
Possible on some farms, not guaranteed: Organic (EU) aquaculture (salmon, trout), Salmon with the ASC label and Naturland aquaculture
Stunning with an effectiveness check: Naturland checks the eye reflex, breathing and muscle twitching. The ASC Farm label requires that at least 95 out of 100 fish are unconscious immediately, and bans CO2, salt baths, ammonia baths and suffocation in air.
Naturland: stunning by blow to the head, electric current or a plant preparation, plus a backup method and a slaughter log. EU organic requires that fish must be "immediately unconscious and insensitive to pain". For the ASC Farm standard, a date from which it applies is missing (state of the explanation 12.11.2024). According to test.de (2012), the suppliers of Aldi Süd, Bofrost, Deutsche See and Eismann stun with a blow after the fish swims through an electronic barrier. Not confirmed: The waiting and driving before stunning is judged by no standard.
What stays open
There is no rule on stunning for wild catch (MSC is silent). Suffocation, crushing or gutting while conscious is usual.
Sources
- MSC standard (no rule on killing the fish)
- AMA-Gütesiegel guideline for fish and fish products, version 2015/1
- BIO AUSTRIA production guidelines, November 2025
- Rung copied from the German table (there based on EU law, a label text or biology, partly without a source of its own; not re-checked for Austria)
- EFSA 2009: killing of rainbow trout (opinion)
- fishcount.org.uk
- faunalytics.org
- Everything on Fish
- How old are fish when they are killed for food?
- Do farmed fish ever see their parents?
- How much space do farmed fish have?
- What does a farmed fish's habitat look like?
- Do farmed fish live outdoors?
- What treatments do farmed fish get?
- How long are live fish transported?
- Label: AMA-Gütesiegel
- Label: BIO AUSTRIA
- Label: Organic (EU)
- Label: MSC (wild fish)
- Label: ASC (farmed fish)
- Label: Naturland aquaculture
- BIO AUSTRIA vs Organic (EU): Fish
- AMA-Gütesiegel vs Organic (EU): Fish
- BIO AUSTRIA vs AMA-Gütesiegel: Fish