Dairy ยท Physical interventions
Are dairy cows' horns removed?
None of the schemes we read bans disbudding. Furthest along: Soil Association organic milk. Weakest: 4 standards, among them Legal minimum (law in England) and Red Tractor Dairy.
Why it is like this
The law makes disbudding an offence without anaesthetic, except chemical cauterisation in the first week. RSPCA Assured, Soil Association and Pasture for Life all allow it within set limits.
What the labels say
| Standard | Level |
|---|---|
| Legal minimum (law in England) | 1 Always, if it makes keeping the animals easier |
| Red Tractor Dairy | 1 Always, if it makes keeping the animals easier |
| RSPCA Assured dairy | 1-2 level 1 guaranteed (Always, if it makes keeping the animals easier); up to level 2 depending on the farm |
| Soil Association organic milk | 2 Only if the animals might otherwise injure themselves with them |
| Pasture for Life (dairy) | 1 Always, if it makes keeping the animals easier |
How we read the levels
- Always, if it makes keeping the animals easier.
- Only if the animals might otherwise injure themselves with them.
- Only if a particular animal needs treatment itself.
- Never. The animal keeps everything it was born with.
Level 1: Always, if it makes keeping the animals easier.
Applies to: Legal minimum (law in England), Red Tractor Dairy, RSPCA Assured dairy and Pasture for Life (dairy)
Disbudding calves is allowed under every rule we read. The law makes it an offence without anaesthetic, except chemical cauterisation in the first week.
Protection of Animals (Anaesthetics) Act 1954, as quoted in the Soil Association text: disbudding or dehorning without anaesthetic is an offence, except chemical cauterisation in the first week (footnote, p.127). RSPCA Assured dairy: disbudding with a hot iron in the first 5 weeks under local anaesthesia, and castration by rubber ring or clamp with a long-acting pain killer but no anaesthetic (H(C) 1.7); pain relief without anaesthesia sits between Level 1 and Level 2. Soil Association: dehorning and disbudding are allowed with anaesthetic by a competent person up to a set age (table, pp.126 to 127). Pasture for Life: castration, disbudding, dehorning and tail docking must be justified in the health plan and kept within the codes (4.5.1), and its own table only recommends pain relief for rubber rings, so it takes the legal level. Soil Association organic milk is at Level 2 (see there).
Level 2: Only if the animals might otherwise injure themselves with them.
Applies to: Soil Association organic milk
Possible on some farms, not guaranteed: RSPCA Assured dairy
Soil Association organic milk sits at Level 2. Disbudding and dehorning must not be routine, need approval case by case and are done with an anaesthetic or pain relief.
Soil Association 3.5.2: tail docking, disbudding and dehorning must not be routine and may be authorised case by case for safety or to improve the health, welfare or hygiene of the animals. Castration is allowed only to keep product quality and traditional practice. Any suffering must be reduced with adequate anaesthesia or pain relief, by qualified people at the most suitable age. The table on pages 126 and 127 lists the methods, the ages and who may carry them out. This follows the organic regulation (Reg 834/2007, Art 14(1)(b)(viii); Reg 889/2008, Art 18), and our scale puts every organic row at Level 2 unless its own text bans more. For cattle the Soil Association text bans no more.
What stays open
The law allows disbudding with anaesthetic. We found no further rule for milk without a scheme.
Sources
- Everything on Dairy
- How long do dairy cows live?
- Are calves separated from their mothers?
- How much room do dairy cows have?
- What do dairy cows lie on?
- Do dairy cows get to graze on pasture?
- How long are cows transported?
- How are dairy cows slaughtered?
- Label: Legal minimum (law in England)
- Label: Red Tractor
- Label: RSPCA Assured
- Label: Soil Association organic
- Label: Pasture for Life
- Legal minimum (law in England) vs Red Tractor: Dairy
- Legal minimum (law in England) vs RSPCA Assured: Dairy
- Legal minimum (law in England) vs Soil Association organic: Dairy
- Legal minimum (law in England) vs Pasture for Life: Dairy