Beef ยท Physical interventions
Are cattle dehorned?
Allowed: disbudding and castration, with an anaesthetic for horn removal. Level at the front: RSPCA Assured beef and Soil Association organic beef. Weakest: 3 standards, among them Legal minimum (law in England) and Red Tractor Beef and Lamb.
Why it is like this
It is an offence to disbud or dehorn cattle without an anaesthetic, except for chemical burning in the first week. RSPCA Assured allows disbudding in the first five weeks and castration up to two months, each with a local anaesthetic and a long-acting pain killer. Soil Association and Pasture for Life require the farm to justify these procedures in its health plan.
What the labels say
| Standard | Level |
|---|---|
| Legal minimum (law in England) | 1 Always, if it makes keeping the animals easier |
| Red Tractor Beef and Lamb | 1 Always, if it makes keeping the animals easier |
| RSPCA Assured beef | 2 Only if the animals might otherwise injure themselves with them |
| Soil Association organic beef | 2 Only if the animals might otherwise injure themselves with them |
| Pasture for Life beef | 1 Always, if it makes keeping the animals easier |
How we read the levels
- Always, if it makes keeping the animals easier.
- Only if the animals might otherwise injure themselves with them.
- Only if a particular animal needs treatment itself.
- Never. The animal keeps everything it was born with.
Level 1: Always, if it makes keeping the animals easier.
Applies to: Legal minimum (law in England), Red Tractor Beef and Lamb and Pasture for Life beef
The law allows disbudding and dehorning, but only with an anaesthetic, except for chemical burning in the first week. Red Tractor has no rule of its own, and Pasture for Life only asks that procedures follow the legal codes.
The Protection of Animals (Anaesthetics) Act 1954, as quoted in the Soil Association standards (page 127 footnote), makes it an offence to disbud calves or dehorn cattle without an anaesthetic, except where chemical cauterisation is used in the first week of life. Red Tractor Beef and Lamb has no rule on horn removal or castration that we found. Pasture for Life 4.5.1 asks for the procedures to be justified in the health plan and to follow the legal codes, and its own table names rubber rings in the first week with pain relief only recommended, so it stays at Level 1.
Level 2: Only if the animals might otherwise injure themselves with them.
Applies to: RSPCA Assured beef and Soil Association organic beef
RSPCA Assured requires a local anaesthetic and a long-acting pain killer for every procedure it allows, castration and disbudding included: Level 2. Soil Association organic beef is at Level 2 as well.
RSPCA Assured lists the procedures it allows: removal of extra teats up to 5 weeks, disbudding with a hot iron in the first 5 weeks, and castration by rubber ring (24 hours to 7 days), clamp or surgery (up to 2 months); at the time of each, a local anaesthetic and a long-acting pain-relieving drug must be given (H(C) 1.8.3). Compulsory anaesthesia is Level 2 on the scale. Soil Association 3.5.2: tail docking, disbudding and dehorning must not be routine and may be authorised case by case for safety or to improve the health, welfare or hygiene of the animals; castration only to maintain product quality and traditional practice; anaesthesia or analgesia and a qualified person are required. The table on pages 126 and 127 lists who may carry out each procedure and up to what age. This follows the organic regulation, and our scale puts every organic row at Level 2 unless its own text bans more. For cattle the Soil Association text bans no more.
What stays open
Red Tractor Beef and Lamb has no rule on horn removal or castration that we found.
Sources
- Everything on Beef
- How long do beef bulls live?
- How long do calves stay with their mother?
- How much space does a fattening bull have?
- What do beef cattle lie on?
- Do beef cattle get out to pasture?
- How long are cattle transported to slaughter?
- How are cattle slaughtered?
- Label: Legal minimum (law in England)
- Label: Red Tractor
- Label: RSPCA Assured
- Label: Soil Association organic
- Label: Pasture for Life
- Legal minimum (law in England) vs Red Tractor: Beef
- Legal minimum (law in England) vs RSPCA Assured: Beef
- Legal minimum (law in England) vs Soil Association organic: Beef
- Legal minimum (law in England) vs Pasture for Life: Beef