Fish ยท Death
How are fish killed?
EU law does not oblige anyone to stun farmed fish before killing. Furthest along: AB aquaculture (EU organic fish). Weakest: 5 standards, among them Wild catch, no label and MSC.
Why it is like this
For fish, Regulation 1099/2009 applies only Article 3(1): avoidable pain, distress and suffering shall be spared. The duty to stun in Article 4 does not cover them. AB asks for slaughter techniques that render fish immediately unconscious. The ASC label exists for farmed fish only. Its Farm Standard, mandatory for every ASC audit from 1 May 2028, requires stunning on a schedule: at once for salmon, after 1 year for trout, after 3 years for sea bass, sea bream and meagre, and then at least 95 of 100 fish unconscious at once and a four-sign check. ASC bans suffocation in air, carbon dioxide baths, salt baths and ammonia baths. A death without fear is reached by no fish product.
What the labels say
| Standard | Level |
|---|---|
| Wild catch, no label | 1 I don't care how it dies |
| MSC | 1 I don't care how it dies |
| Farmed fish (legal minimum) | 1 I don't care how it dies |
| ASC (aquaculture) | 1-3 level 1 guaranteed (I don't care how it dies); up to level 3 depending on the farm |
| AB aquaculture (EU organic fish) | 2 It may feel brief fear or pain if it is quick |
| Label Rouge fish (salmon, trout, sea bass, bream) | 1 I don't care how it dies |
How we read the levels
- I don't care how it dies.
- It may feel brief fear or pain if it is quick.
- It should feel no pain, even if it may be afraid beforehand.
- It should die without fear and without pain, and notice nothing of it.
Level 1: I don't care how it dies.
Applies to: Wild catch, no label, MSC, Farmed fish (legal minimum), ASC (aquaculture) and Label Rouge fish (salmon, trout, sea bass, bream)
For farmed fish, EU law has no duty to stun before killing. It only asks to spare the fish avoidable pain. Label Rouge fish are scored at this legal floor because we read no rule of theirs on this point. Wild fish, with or without MSC, are scored 1 for another reason: no rule covers how they die. Most suffocate or are crushed in the net or on board, without stunning, and this is the hardest point of their life.
Regulation (EC) 1099/2009 Article 1(1): 'as regards fish, only the requirements laid down in Article 3(1) shall apply'. Article 3(1): animals shall be spared any avoidable pain, distress or suffering during their killing and related operations. The stunning duty of Article 4 therefore does not bind farmed fish. This is the legal minimum row, scored 1. It is also the low end of ASC, a label for farmed fish only: for sea bass and sea bream the ASC stunning duty is not yet in force, and salmon farms may be audited against the older ASC salmon standard, which has no stunning rule, until 1 May 2028. We found no French rule that goes further. Under our scoring rule, a row whose rule was not read takes the legal value as its floor ('at least the law'): Label Rouge fish sit here for that reason.
Level 2: It may feel brief fear or pain if it is quick.
Applies to: AB aquaculture (EU organic fish)
Possible on some farms, not guaranteed: ASC (aquaculture)
Fish are to be made unconscious and insensible to pain. AB says slaughter techniques must render fish immediately unconscious, with no check of this, so AB is scored 2.
Regulation (EU) 2018/848 Annex II Part III 3.1.6.9: slaughter techniques shall render fish immediately unconscious and insensible to pain, and handling before slaughter shall avoid injuries and keep suffering and stress to a minimum. Nothing in the AB text requires a check of the stun. ASC (Farm Standard V1.0.1A2) 4.1.3.2: all fish are stunned before killing by the methods and within the transition periods of Appendix 12 Table 5 (percussion, electrical, anaesthetic overdose). For sea bass, sea bream and meagre the transition period is 3 years from the issue date of the standard, for trout 1 year, for salmon 'immediate'. For bass and bream on the French counter the duty is not yet in force. The Farm Standard becomes mandatory for every ASC audit only on 1 May 2028; until then salmon farms may still be audited against the older salmon standard. ASC is therefore scored 1 to 3.
Level 3: It should feel no pain, even if it may be afraid beforehand.
Possible on some farms, not guaranteed: ASC (aquaculture)
Stunning with an effectiveness check. The ASC Farm Standard requires that at least 95 of 100 fish lose consciousness at once and that the stun is checked against four signs. It binds every ASC farm only from 1 May 2028.
ASC Farm Standard V1.0.1A2: 4.1.3.3 at least 95 % of fish lose consciousness immediately after stunning, others are re-stunned, and unconsciousness lasts until death. 4.1.3.4 the stun is checked for the absence of opercular (gill) movements, eye movements, body movements except involuntary spasms, and reaction to a painful stimulus. 4.1.3.5 a back-up system. 4.1.3.6 bans asphyxiation in air, carbon dioxide bath, salt bath, ammonia bath and evisceration as killing methods. The AB rule has the immediacy requirement without these checks. No fish product reaches rung 4, dying without fear and pain.
What stays open
Wild fish and MSC: we found no written rule on how they are killed, so both stay at level 1. Farmed Label Rouge fish: the rule books were not read, so the row is scored at the legal floor.
Further reading
- EUR-Lex: Regulation (EC) 1099/2009, killing of animals (Legal text)
- EUR-Lex: Regulation (EU) 2018/848, organic production (Legal text)
- ASC: Farm Standard V1.0.1A2, August 2026 (Standard, PDF)
Sources
- Everything on Fish
- How old are fish when they are killed for food?
- Do farmed fish ever see their parents?
- How much space do farmed fish have?
- What does a farmed fish's habitat look like?
- Do farmed fish live outdoors?
- What treatments do farmed fish get?
- How long are live fish transported?
- Label: Wild-caught fish without a label
- Label: MSC (wild fish)
- Label: Legal minimum (EU and French law)
- Label: ASC (farmed fish)
- Label: AB / EU organic
- Label: Label Rouge
- Legal minimum (EU and French law) vs Label Rouge: Fish
- Legal minimum (EU and French law) vs AB / EU organic: Fish
- Label Rouge vs AB / EU organic: Fish