How my food lives
Australia
EN

Fish ยท Death

How are fish killed?

Last updated: November 2026

No fish product promises a death without fear. Furthest along: Certified organic aquaculture (National Standard 3.8, s 1.24). Weakest: Wild-caught fish, no label and Wild-caught fish with MSC label.

Why it is like this

Wild-caught fish, with or without MSC, mostly suffocate in air or are gutted alive without a stun. Farmed fish are still commonly killed by suffocation, CO2, cold or bleeding without stunning, which take several minutes to work. The RSPCA salmon standard requires stunning within a second and bans those methods, but no producer has been certified to it since March 2025. Organic allows ice slurry and CO2.

What the labels say

StandardLevel
Wild-caught fish, no label1 I don't care how it dies
Wild-caught fish with MSC label1 I don't care how it dies
Farmed salmon, no label (state law not read)no fixed rule
Farmed salmon with ASC label (Salmon Standard v1.4)no fixed rule
Certified organic aquaculture (National Standard 3.8, s 1.24)1-2 level 1 guaranteed (I don't care how it dies); up to level 2 depending on the farm
How we read the levels
  1. I don't care how it dies.
  2. It may feel brief fear or pain if it is quick.
  3. It should feel no pain, even if it may be afraid beforehand.
  4. It should die without fear and without pain, and notice nothing of it.

Level 1: I don't care how it dies.

Applies to: Wild-caught fish, no label, Wild-caught fish with MSC label and Certified organic aquaculture (National Standard 3.8, s 1.24)

Wild-caught fish sit here, with or without MSC: most suffocate in air or are gutted alive, without stunning.

Fishcount says wild-caught fish are generally not stunned, and that putting live fish on ice is stressful. MSC certifies the fishery, not the way a fish dies.

Level 2: It may feel brief fear or pain if it is quick.

Possible on some farms, not guaranteed: Certified organic aquaculture (National Standard 3.8, s 1.24)

Stunned before slaughter, but with no check that it worked. No label in our table sits only at this rung. Organic aquaculture reaches it at most.

The organic standard asks that slaughter minimise stress and suffering (1.18.6) and allows ice slurry or CO2 for sedation (1.24.13), so it sits at 1 to 2.

What stays open

We found no rule on how unlabelled farmed fish are killed, and could not confirm whether Australian law requires a stun. The RSPCA says suffocation, CO2, cold and bleeding without a stun are still common for farmed fish and take several minutes to work.

Sources

More on this